BankBI fits credit unions that want to stop building the board pack in Excel, because it produces the monthly board pack, daily statements, budgets, and profitability from the same core banking and general ledger data, loaded every day and set up by BankBI.
Other alternatives to Excel are planning suites such as Jack Henry's Financial Performance Suite and Plansmith, planning inside Excel with Vena, peer data from Callahan & Associates, and data and close tools such as Arkatechture and Trintech.
In a credit union that reports in Excel, the Manager of Finance or Controller rebuilds the board pack each month from figures copied out of the core banking system and the general ledger (the accounting record). If only the person who built the workbook can run it, a sick day puts the pack at risk, yet the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) still presents it to the board. Each type of alternative fixes a different part of that problem:
- Figures are keyed in by hand and errors creep in: a daily reporting platform loads core and general ledger data every day and produces statements, dashboards, and the board pack.
- The budget is the hardest workbook: a planning suite builds budgets and forecasts, and some link them to asset liability management, which tracks interest rate and liquidity risk.
- The team wants to stay in Excel: planning inside Excel keeps the spreadsheet as the interface, with governed data behind it.
- The board asks how you compare: a peer data provider benchmarks your results against similar credit unions on call report data.
- Analysts need data from every system: a data warehouse holds data from many systems in one place.
- Reconciliations live in spreadsheets: close software automates account reconciliations and tracks close tasks.
This guide compares seven options on four points:
- Where the data comes from, and whether collecting it is automated
- How the board pack and management reports are produced
- How the figures are checked between the core and the general ledger
- Who sets the system up and runs it day to day
Alternatives to Excel for Credit Union Board Packs Compared
The table sets out each option and the kind of credit union work it suits.
| Provider and type | Ideal for |
|---|---|
| BankBI, reporting and planning platform | Board pack, daily reports, budgeting, and profitability from core and general ledger data |
| Jack Henry Financial Performance Suite, planning and risk suite | Forecasting, asset liability management, profitability, and a daily dashboard |
| Plansmith, budgeting and rate risk software | Budgets, forecasts, rate risk, and board reporting in Compass |
| Vena, planning inside Excel | Planning, reporting, and board presentations through Microsoft tools |
| Callahan & Associates, peer data provider | Peer benchmarking for credit unions on call report data |
| Arkatechture, managed data warehouse | Data from many systems in one place for analysts |
| Trintech, reconciliation and close software | Balance sheet reconciliations, transaction matching, and close tasks |
In short: BankBI reports and plans from the same daily data, planning suites focus on budgets and rate risk, Vena keeps Excel as the interface, Callahan adds peer comparison, and Arkatechture and Trintech do jobs that sit alongside the board pack.
How We Compared These Alternatives to Excel
- Criteria: where the data comes from, how the board pack is produced, how the figures are checked, and who sets the system up and runs it.
- Method: a review of public sources, mainly each provider's own website. We didn't test any product, and we give no scores or rankings.
- Date: November 2026. Features change, so check each vendor's current information.
- Sources: each provider's facts come from the page linked in its entry.
The Seven Alternatives to Excel for Credit Union Board Packs
1. BankBI
BankBI is a reporting and planning platform for credit unions, built on your own core banking and general ledger data. It automates the monthly board pack and management reports, and reports your balance sheet and income statement every day, from the same figures your finance team uses.
- Automated board pack: monthly management and board reporting, delivered as automated PDF reports.
- Daily statements and KPIs: a daily balance sheet, income statement, and dashboard of key performance indicators (KPIs), readable on a tablet or phone, with KPI Tree Analysis to drill down into the statements.
- Daily reconciliation: a daily reconciliation report compares general ledger balances with core banking data to identify potential differences.
- Planning in the same platform: Planning, Budgeting & Forecasting builds annual budgets, rolling forecasts, and multi-year plans next to the reporting, with actuals uploaded from your general ledger.
- Free peer analysis: a free peer analysis on National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) Call Report data, with over 25 performance reports and a quarterly PDF results pack.
- Profitability after funding costs: Profit Analyzer, BankBI's funds transfer pricing application, assigns funding costs and fee income across products, branches, and segments, so profitability shows after funding.
Data arrives through pre-built connections, named by system:
- Symitar: standard PowerOn scripts extract the data.
- Fiserv DNA: BankBI helps you set up a scheduled daily query, with no dedicated connection to the core.
- Corelation KeyStone: Yolo Federal Credit Union and IH Credit Union use an extract co-developed by BankBI and Corelation.
- Fiserv Prologue and FAS: daily standard extracts that keep your general ledger codes.
- Other named systems: CBX, CU*BASE, Fiserv Premier, and the PhoenixWorx Phoenix core banking system. If your core isn't listed, BankBI asks you to get in touch.
BankBI's implementation team maps your data once and takes care of the hard work, and your team confirms the reconciled results. In BankBI's words, core banking systems weren't designed to be business performance reporting systems.
Ideal Credit Union revamped its 30-page monthly board pack with BankBI. As its EVP and Chief Financial Officer put it: “What we really wanted to do was move away from Excel-based reporting and move instead to something more automated.”
2. Jack Henry Financial Performance Suite
Jack Henry's Financial Performance Suite (FPS) is one hosted system of financial management tools for banks and credit unions. It has five parts:
- Asset Liability Management, to manage risk
- Forecasting and Financial Reporting, a budgeting system that forecasts the balance sheet
- Daily Dashboard, refreshed by a nightly feed from multiple core sources
- Organizational Profitability, to find profitable branches, departments, and regions
- CECL Solutions, for the current expected credit loss (CECL) accounting standard
Jack Henry states that FPS works with all core vendors, so you don't need a Jack Henry core to use it. The finance department is its main user, and branch managers and loan officers follow daily changes on the Daily Dashboard.
3. Plansmith
Plansmith sells software and expertise to banks and credit unions, and its team describes themselves as former community bankers. Its Financial Compass software automates budgeting, forecasting, and reporting, interfaces with core systems, and produces board reporting.
Plansmith has combined budgeting and asset liability management into one module, and lists automated rate risk among Compass's features. Compass is built to replace complicated budgeting spreadsheets and the manual entry of data, which suits a credit union whose hardest workbook is the annual budget.
4. Vena
Vena connects financial planning, analysis, and reporting for banks and credit unions through the Microsoft tools your team already uses. On its banking page, Vena lists:
- Governed Excel templates for collecting budgets and forecasts across branches and departments
- Reports, charts, and financial statements that refresh while staying consistent
- Board and management presentations built from connected financial data
- Integration with financial and core banking systems through connectors
For a finance team that wants to keep working in Excel, Vena keeps the spreadsheet in front and governs the data behind it.
5. Callahan & Associates
Callahan & Associates provides peer data to credit unions through Peer Suite, which benchmarks your performance against peers on industry call report data. It gives access to the same Financial Performance Reports the NCUA provides, along with dashboards, scoring systems, merger analysis, and projections.
A beta AI Analysis feature writes a summary comparing your credit union with its peers, which can be exported for board packets and leadership updates. Callahan says its Premium Library helps you walk into conversations with the board and examiners ready to explain the story behind the data. CU Profiles, the free part of Peer Suite, shows how your credit union compares with its peers.
6. Arkatechture
Arkatechture serves credit unions and banks with business intelligence tools, expertise, and training. Its Arkalytics platform is a software as a service (SaaS) data warehouse with business intelligence and predictive analytics, used to automate reports, build dashboards, and give staff self-service access to data.
A fully managed package includes implementation, hosting, and a data strategy roadmap. Arkatechture also runs scoped dashboard and analytics projects, or provides analytics experts who work alongside your team to design reporting. It fits credit unions that want data from many systems in one place for analysis across the organization.
7. Trintech
Trintech sells financial close and reconciliation software to credit unions, through its Adra, Cadency, and ReconNET products. The software automates high-volume transaction matching, balance sheet reconciliations, and exception tracking, in place of spreadsheet-based close workflows. Trintech describes the aim as less manual work and stronger control over the close.
Trintech also manages close documentation for audit readiness. Its job is the close itself, proving each account balance, so it runs alongside the platform that builds the board pack from the closed figures.
What to Look for in an Alternative to Excel for Credit Union Board Packs
Build the Board Pack from the Figures Finance Uses
When the board pack is rebuilt in Excel, every page is a fresh copy of figures that already exist in your systems, and every copy is a chance for an error. Ask for a pack produced from the same data as your daily reports, so the board and the finance team see the same numbers.
BankBI automates the monthly board pack and management PDF reports from the same daily core and general ledger data as its dashboards. SRP Federal Credit Union, whose budgeting had been manual and spreadsheet-heavy, used BankBI to produce board-ready outputs its finance committee could examine. Vena takes a different route: governed Excel templates, with board presentations built from connected data.
Collect Data Automatically from Your Core and General Ledger
A tool that only formats a report still needs someone to key in the figures. Ask each vendor whether it collects the data itself, from which systems, and how often. The common routes are:
- Scripts or queries in your core: BankBI uses standard PowerOn scripts for Symitar and a scheduled daily query for Fiserv DNA.
- An extract built with the core vendor: BankBI and Corelation co-developed the KeyStone extract that Yolo and IH run.
- Daily general ledger extracts: for Fiserv Prologue and FAS, with your general ledger codes kept.
BankBI's integrations page names its systems, which for US credit unions include Symitar, Corelation KeyStone, Fiserv DNA, CBX, CU*BASE, and other named systems. Plansmith states that Compass interfaces with core systems for budgeting; BankBI loads core and general ledger data every day for reporting and the board pack.
Check the General Ledger Against the Core Every Day
A board pack is only as reliable as the match between the core banking system and the general ledger. The standard to ask for is a check that runs every day and shows where the two differ.
BankBI's daily reconciliation report compares general ledger balances with core banking data to identify potential differences. With Fiserv Prologue and FAS, it keeps your general ledger codes, so figures trace back to the general ledger. Ask any vendor what happens when a difference appears, and who sees it first.
Make Sure the Pack Doesn't Depend on One Person
If only one person can update the workbook, the pack is at risk whenever they're away. Look for a system the vendor sets up and maintains, so your finance team reviews the figures instead of building them.
BankBI provides a one-off data mapping through its Integrations Hub. Its implementation team takes care of the hard work, and your team confirms the reconciled results.
Use Data Warehouses and Close Tools Alongside Your Reporting
Two jobs sit next to the board pack rather than inside it. A data warehouse such as Arkatechture's Arkalytics holds data from many systems for analysts, and close software such as Trintech's handles balance sheet reconciliations and close tasks.
Both can run alongside BankBI, which builds the figures and the pack. A credit union that already has a data warehouse can keep it.
How to Choose the Right Alternative to Excel for Your Credit Union
Step 1: Name the Problem You're Solving
Start with what goes wrong today, because each answer points to a different need:
- Errors in the figures: look for automated data collection and a daily check against the general ledger.
- The time it takes: look for a pack produced from daily data, not rebuilt each month.
- Only one person can run it: look for a vendor that sets the system up and maintains the data mapping.
Then set the scope: the board pack, management reporting, or all financial reporting. Count the spreadsheets your team maintains and note which ones feed the pack, so every vendor quotes for the same job.
Step 2: Check the Connection to Your Core and General Ledger
Name your core banking system and general ledger, and ask each vendor whether it connects to them today, who builds the connection, and who maintains it. Bring your information technology (IT) lead into this step. If your system isn't on a vendor's list, ask what happens next.
Step 3: Decide Who Will Run It
Match the system to the people you have. If your finance team is small, favor software the vendor sets up, with reports ready to use: BankBI maps your data once and your team checks the reconciled results. If you have analysts on staff, a data warehouse or a planning suite your team runs becomes realistic.
Step 4: Plan the Move Off Excel
Moving the board pack is the step that decides whether the switch works. Plan it in three parts:
- Back up and map your history: archive every workbook that feeds the pack, and list which figures come from the core, the general ledger, or manual entry.
- Run a pilot on your own data: Ideal Credit Union gave BankBI about two months of its data to test, and its board and asset and liability committee (ALCO) then said yes.
- Keep a way back: produce the Excel pack and the new pack side by side until the figures match, so you can return to the workbook if the pilot falls short.
Ask each vendor how much history it loads at setup, and how past packs are kept.
Step 5: When to Choose a Reporting and Planning Platform Built on Daily Core and General Ledger Data
If your board pack is rebuilt in Excel each month and your budget sits in another workbook, choose a platform that produces the pack from daily core and general ledger data and holds the plan too. SRP Federal Credit Union built a 2026 budget in BankBI that its finance committee approved, then extended it into a five-year plan in the same model.
To see how it would work with your systems, book a consultation with BankBI.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are the Best Alternatives to Excel for Credit Union Board Packs and Financial Reporting?
It depends on the job. For the board pack and financial reporting from one set of data, BankBI produces the monthly pack, daily statements, budgets, and profitability from your core and general ledger, set up by its own team. For budgets and rate risk, Jack Henry's Financial Performance Suite and Plansmith fit; Vena keeps Excel as the interface, and Callahan & Associates supplies peer data.
Do Excel Alternatives Automatically Reconcile Core Banking and General Ledger Data?
Only if the tool collects data from both systems, because a tool that formats figures you supply can't check them. BankBI runs a daily reconciliation report that compares general ledger balances with core banking data to identify potential differences. With Fiserv Prologue and FAS, it keeps your general ledger codes, so each figure traces back to the general ledger.
Do Excel Alternatives for Credit Unions Require a Data Warehouse?
Not if the tool connects to your systems directly. BankBI integrates directly with your core banking system and takes general ledger data through standard extracts, with pre-built connections for Symitar, Corelation KeyStone, Fiserv DNA, CBX, CU*BASE, and other named systems. A data warehouse does a different job, holding data from many systems for analysts, and it can run alongside BankBI.
Can a Credit Union Move Off Excel Without IT Involvement?
Mostly, if the vendor does the setup. BankBI's implementation team handles the data mapping, your finance team confirms the reconciled results, and the cloud platform needs no upfront investment in infrastructure. Your IT lead still helps at the start, for example to give access to the core and general ledger, and can ask any vendor where its software runs.
What Does Board Pack Software Cost Compared with Keeping Excel?
Prices depend on the vendor, so ask each one for a quote based on your credit union, modules, and users; BankBI doesn't publish prices on its website. To compare with Excel, count the staff hours spent each month keying, checking, and formatting the pack, and weigh what happens if the person who runs it leaves. BankBI needs no upfront investment in infrastructure, and its team does the data mapping.
Can an Excel Alternative Keep Our Spreadsheet History and an Audit Trail?
Keep your existing workbooks as an archive, whichever tool you choose. Then ask each vendor how much history it loads from your core and general ledger at setup, how past board packs are stored, and how it records who changed a figure and when. With BankBI, the daily reconciliation report and the general ledger codes kept from Fiserv Prologue and FAS show where figures came from.
Making the Right Excel Alternative Choice for Your Credit Union
If your board pack is rebuilt in Excel each month and depends on one or two people, BankBI gives your finance team the pack, daily statements, the budget, and profitability from the same core and general ledger data, set up by BankBI. The other options each take on one job:
- Planning suites such as Jack Henry FPS and Plansmith: choose one when the budget and rate risk are the main concern.
- Planning inside Excel with Vena: choose it when your team wants to stay in Excel.
- Peer data from Callahan & Associates: choose it when the board's main question is how you compare.
Stay with Excel for now if your pack is short, more than one person can build it, and your board is satisfied with it. Excel also stays useful for one-off analysis.
Some jobs sit alongside BankBI rather than in place of it: a data warehouse such as Arkatechture's serves analysts across many systems, and close software such as Trintech's handles reconciliations and close tasks.
Why BankBI Is the Right Choice for Credit Union Board Packs and Financial Reporting
BankBI is the right choice for credit unions that want the board pack and financial reporting out of Excel and built from daily data.
- Board pack from daily data: the monthly pack and management PDF reports come from the figures finance works with every day.
- Data collected for you: pre-built connections to Symitar, Corelation KeyStone, Fiserv DNA, CBX, CU*BASE, and other named systems.
- Figures checked daily: a daily reconciliation report compares general ledger balances with core banking data.
- Set up by BankBI: its implementation team maps your data once, so the pack doesn't rest on one spreadsheet expert.
- Planning and profitability in one place: budgets, rolling forecasts, multi-year plans, and Profit Analyzer for profitability after funding costs.
One set of core and general ledger data feeds the board pack, the daily statements and KPIs, the budget, and profitability. For your CFO, that means the figures in front of the board are the ones finance checks every day, not a copy rebuilt at month-end. Read more about BankBI's daily financial reporting.
To see your own figures in BankBI, book a consultation with BankBI.
